
CORPORATE, FINANCE
Tuesday, 15 March 2022
2004 GEPF members booklet VS todays GEPF member guide
Comparing the 2004 GEPF Member Booklet to Today’s Membership Guide: What Has Changed?
In 2004, the Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF) published a Member Booklet that served as a critical reference for fund members. It was comprehensive, detailing essential aspects of the fund’s rules, specifically Schedule 1 of the GEP Law. Fast forward to 2024, and we have the GEPF Membership Guide, a document that, while still informative, has departed significantly from its predecessor in both content and focus. The 2024 guide neither summarizes the rules of the fund as the 2004 booklet did, nor does it claim to serve this purpose. This shift raises important questions for members who rely on these materials to make informed decisions.
Facts: Key Differences and Missing Information
The 2004 booklet provided a detailed summary of the rules, ensuring members had access to all necessary information, especially around actuarial calculations that impact exit decisions. In contrast, today’s guide omits essential material such as actuarial interest formulas and factors that are crucial for members, particularly when making decisions about retirement or exiting the fund.
1. Missing Actuarial Interest Formulas and Factors
- 2004 Booklet: Actuarial interest formulas and factors were clearly outlined. Members could see precisely how these figures applied to specific exit scenarios, such as resignations or other exits with less than ten years of pensionable service.
- 2024 Guide: This information has been entirely removed, leaving members without a clear understanding of how their benefits are calculated upon exiting. This omission restricts members' ability to make well-informed decisions about their futures, given that they are no longer equipped with the knowledge they had in 2004.
2. Inconsistencies and Omissions
- Today’s guide is not only inconsistent with the 2004 version but also with the rules of the fund and the GEP Law itself. The absence of actuarial details results in a document that feels incomplete and, arguably, less reliable than the original booklet. The lack of transparency around benefit calculations may contribute to members feeling uncertain about their entitlements.
Legislative Updates: New Additions in Today’s Guide
In the latest guide, certain legislative updates have been added, ostensibly to keep members informed about changes. However, some of these updates are controversial and have raised concerns about legality and transparency.
1. Introduction of Pension Interest and Divorce Debt*
- The 2024 guide introduces definitions such as “Pension Interest” and “Divorce Debt,” providing guidance on how pension entitlements are impacted by divorce settlements. While these additions are relevant in today’s context, they add complexity without additional guidance on how they affect the overall benefit calculations for members.
2. Payslips as Proof of Membership – Is It Legal?
- The guide also introduces payslips as proof of membership, which has been flagged as potentially unlawful. Traditionally, membership certification came in the form of a membership certificate. Requiring payslips as proof is not stipulated anywhere in the GEPF statutes, making it a questionable addition that could place undue burden on members.
3. Membership Certificates as “Verification”
- Membership certificates, once the undisputed proof of membership, are now described as tools for information verification rather than legal proof of membership. This shift is confusing for members who have always relied on the certificate for validation. Is this change genuinely aimed at improving information accuracy, or does it create unnecessary ambiguity?
Education: Important Points for Members to Understand
1. The Role of the Fund as Custodian of Contribution Records
- The fund, or its administrators, is responsible for maintaining members’ contribution records. Members should not need to rely on payslips to prove their contributions, as the fund is the only legitimate record holder of these contributions. This is a critical point for members to be aware of to avoid unnecessary documentation requirements.
2. Legal Requirements Around Membership Proof
- The only lawful proof of membership remains the membership certificate, which all members should have and retain indefinitely. This certificate, and not payslips, should be the sole documentation proving their association with the fund.
3. The Unlawful Omission of Actuarial Interest Formulas
- Removing actuarial interest formulas and factors from the 2024 guide could be seen as unlawful. These factors are central to calculating members' benefits, and their omission is both a transparency issue and a potential legal oversight. Members deserve clarity around benefit calculations, especially since the 2004 booklet established a precedent for this transparency.
Closing Thoughts: Why Are Actuarial Formulas Missing?
The changes between the 2004 and 2024 guides reflect a significant shift in how the GEPF communicates with its members. The absence of actuarial interest formulas and factors in the latest guide is particularly troubling. These calculations are fundamental for any member considering an exit. Without them, members are left in the dark, unable to understand the full financial implications of their decisions.
In the 2004 booklet, actuarial factors and formulas were given a dedicated section, underscoring their importance. The 2024 guide, however, lacks this critical information without explanation. This omission prompts members to ask: Why has the GEPF chosen to exclude this essential content? Transparency, consistency, and member empowerment should be the guiding principles of any member document. Hopefully, future updates will address these gaps and restore a level of clarity and completeness that aligns with members’ needs and legal expectations.
GET IN TOUCH
Deal Activities
University of Natal (Durban): Workshops on Worker Finances for COSATU in KZN.
South African Post Office: Retirement Fund Member Communication and Financial Literacy
Individual Clients: Personal services ranging from individual business assurance, investments, retirement funds and medical aid
Thekwini Business Development Centre (TBDC): Wealth Planning workshop for the historically disadvantaged employees.
Africa Vukani
078 457 0964
(031) 100 1017
9 Dorothy Nyembe Street
(Gardener Street)
Durban Central